Ad Fontes ← Search Library Verse Index

1 Samuel 17:1–17:58

David and GoliathTheme: Faith / Courage / Typology / ChristPericopeImportance: Major
Sources
Reformed ConsensusReformation Study BibleGeneva Bible Notes (1599)John Trapp (1647)John Gill (1748)Matthew Henry (1714)Jamieson-Fausset-BrownBarnes (1832)Cross-References (TSK)
Reformed Consensus
The contest between David and Goliath is not primarily a story of human courage but of covenant faithfulness: Goliath's taunt is an affront to the living God, and David's response — "the battle is the LORD's" (v. 47) — establishes the theological center of the narrative, as Calvin observes that David's confidence rests entirely on divine promise rather than any assessment of his own ability. Matthew Henry underscores that God deliberately ordained the improbability of the match so that no flesh might glory in His presence, making the shepherd boy's sling the instrument by which the Lord exposes the bankruptcy of trusting in human armament. The Reformers consistently read David here as a typological figure whose victory anticipates the greater Champion, Christ, who in apparent weakness defeated the enemy of God's people and vindicated the honor of His Father's name before the nations. John Gill notes that David's refusal of Saul's armor is a pointed rebuke of fleshly wisdom: the Spirit-equipped servant of God needs no worldly resources when he goes to battle in the name of the LORD of hosts. The passage thus calls the covenant community to a faith that stakes everything on God's word and power rather than visible, creaturely means — a principle the Reformed tradition has consistently enshrined as sola gratia in both soteriology and providence.
Reformation Study Bible
between Socoh and Azekah, in Ephes-dammim. Socoh was fif- teen miles west of Bethlehem, near the Philistine border, and Azekah was two miles northwest of Socoh. | Valley of Elah. The valley descends from east to west, passing just north of Socoh and Azekah. | champion. Trial by single combat, where the outcome of a fight to the death between two champions is taken as the will of the gods, is rare in the Old Testament (compare 2 Sam. 2:14-16). It is well attested, how- ever, among some of Israel's neighbors. six cubits and a span. That is, nine feet, nine inches. The Septuagint (Greek Old Testament translation), Dead Sea Scrolls, and Josephus (Antiquities 6.9.1) all have four cubits instead of six, making Goliath six and a half feet tall, still a remarkable height by ancient standards. | The detailed description of Goliath's armor and weapons is strik- ing. David does not have to trust in equipment (vv. 39, 50). | Saul. The Philistine challenge to the “servants of Saul” had been to “choose a man’ (v. 8). The logical choice would have been Saul (9:2; 10:23, 24), but he was terrified like everyone else. | Ephrathite. See Gen. 35:19; 48:7; Ruth 1:2; 4:11; 1 Chr. 4:4; Mic. 52. | David went back and forth from Saul. David's time was split between duties to his king (16:21-23) and to his father. David's whole family is introduced with him (wv. 12-14). | give him his daughter. See notes 18:17-19, 20-27. | uncircumcised Philistine. See note 14:6. | Eliab’s anger was kindled. Eliab's sudden anger is the reaction of aman who was unable to meet a challenge and who resented being out- done by his little brother. David's having been anointed would only increase Eliab’s jealousy. In Genesis 37, Joseph's older brothers react in the same way to the knowledge that he would one day be superior to them (Gen, 37:2-19). with whom have you left those few sheep. Whatever his excitement about the battle, David had acted responsibly in regard to his more mun- dane duties (vv. 20, 22). your presumption, Or, “your insolence.” the evil of your heart. Contrast Eliab’s judgment of David with God's, as indicated by statements like “a man after his own heart” (13:14), and “the Lord looks on the heart” (16:7). | The conversation between Saul and David vividly illustrates the radical difference in perspective between them. Saul continues to think in terms of what is humanly possible ("You are not able/"'v. 33), while David is confident that “The Lorb ... will deliver me” (v. 37). 17:36 uncircumcised Philistine. See 14:6 note. | the Loro be with you. David's rise to power continues to be fur- thered, if unwittingly, by Saul, Having brought him into his court (16:19 note), Saul now sends him out to fight his battle. Most ironic of all, Saul invokes over David the benediction that most clearly distinguishes them and will account for David's ultimate success—"the Loro be with you" (16:18 and note). | David's rejection of Saul’s armor and weapons supports the point of the narrative that “the LorD saves not with sword and spear. For the battle is the Lorp’s” (v. 47). | in the name of the Lorp of hosts. See note 1:3. David comes “in the name” of God, that is, by the authority and power of God. On the sig- nificance of God's name as expressing His character, see, for example, Ex. 34:5-7. | dead bodies . . . of the Philistines. David outdoes Goliath's threat (v. 44) by extending his counterthreat to encompass the entire Philistine army. | battle is the Lorp’s. See notes on wy. 38, 39; 14:6. 17:50 killed. That is, dealt him the mortal wound (v. 51) note. There was no sword. This verse marks the climax of the contest between Goliath, who physically speaking had all the advantages, and David, who had God on his side, and was able to triumph even without a sword (cf. vv. 45-47). | killed. A different form of the Hebrew verb is used than in v. 50; the sense is “dispatched, as in 14:13. | Gath and Ekron. See notes 4:1; 5:8, 10. | brought it to Jerusalem. Since Jerusalem was at this time in Jebusite hands (2 Sam. 5:6-9 and notes), this remark should be under- stood as referring to a later time. | whose son is this youth. Saul’s question and Abner’s response appear to conflict with the events described in 16:18-22. At the same time a chronological relationship between chs. 16 and 17 seems to be warranted (v.15 and 18:2). Saul’s question may have been prompted by concerns about the social status of someone who might receive the posi- tion promised in 17:25, including marriage to his daughter. The intensity of Saul’s interest may also reflect his knowledge that the kingdom will ultimately be given to “a neighbor of yours, who is better than you" (15:28). See 18:8 and note.
Geneva Bible Notes (1599)
Now the Philistines gathered together their armies to battle, and were gathered together at Shochoh, which belongeth to Judah, and pitched between Shochoh and Azekah, in Ephesdammim.
John Trapp (1647)
Now the Philistines gathered together their armies to battle, and were gathered together at Shochoh, which [belongeth] to Judah, and pitched between Shochoh and Azekah, in Ephesdammim. Now the Philistines gathered together. — They hearing of the breach between Saul and Samuel, whose piety and prayers had been dreadful and baneful to them, as also of Saul’s frantic fits, rendering him unfit to lead an army; but especially being stirred up by God to undertake this expedition for the accomplishment of his ends, they again invade the land of Israel: “ Atque Philisthaeis redit in praecordia virtus. ”
John Gill (1748)
Now the Philistines gathered together their armies to battle,.... Josephus (s) says this was not long after the things related in the preceding chapter were transacted; and very probably they had heard of the melancholy and distraction of Saul, and thought it a proper opportunity of avenging themselves on Israel for their last slaughter of them, and for that purpose gathered together their dispersed troops: and were gathered together at Shochoh, which belongeth to Judah; a city of the tribe of Judah, Joshua 15:35 , which shows that, notwithstanding their last defeat, they had great footing in the land of Israel, or however had penetrated far into it in this march of theirs: and pitched between Shochoh and Azekah; which were both in the same tribe, and near one another, of which See Gill on Joshua 10:10 ; see Gill on Joshua 15:35 . in Ephesdammim; which, by an apocope of the first letter, is called Pasdammim, 1 Chronicles 11:13 which the Jews (t) say had this name because there blood ceased. (s) Antiqu. l. 6. c. 9. sect. 1.((t) Midrash Ruth, fol. 48. 2. Kimchi in loc.
Matthew Henry (1714)
Men so entirely depend upon God in all things, that when he withdraws his help, the most valiant and resolute cannot find their hearts or hands, as daily experience shows.
Jamieson-Fausset-Brown
CHAPTER 17 1Sa 17:1-3. The Israelites and Philistines Being Ready to Battle. 1. the Philistines gathered together their armies—twenty-seven years after their overthrow at Michmash. Having now recovered their spirits and strength, they sought an opportunity of wiping out the infamy of that national disaster, as well as to regain their lost ascendency over Israel. Shocoh—now Shuweikeh, a town in the western plains of Judah (Jos 15:35), nine Roman miles from Eleutheropolis, toward Jerusalem [Robinson]. Azekah—a small place in the neighborhood. Ephes-dammim—or, "Pas-dammim" (1Ch 11:13), "the portion" or "effusion of blood," situated between the other two.The armies of the Israelites and Philistines ready for battle: Goliath terrifieth the Israelites with his stature, armour, and challenge, 1 Samuel 17:1-11 . David sent by his father to visit his brethren; is willing to encounter with him, 1 Samuel 17:12-27 ; for which Eliab chideth him: he is brought to Saul, and showeth the reason of his confidence, 1 Samuel 17:28-37 . He taketh a staff, and sling, with five stones, 1 Samuel 17:38 . Goliath curseth and threateneth him, 1 Samuel 17:41-44 . David’s faith: he slayeth him, 1 Samuel 17:45-50 . The Philistines flee; are smitten and plundered, 1 Samuel 17:51-54 . Saul taketh notice of David, 1 Samuel 17:55-58 . To revenge their former great and shameful defeat, 1Sa 14 .
Barnes (1832)
The narrative reverts to the Philistine wars 1 Samuel 14:52 ; the other introductory details concerning Saul's rejection, and David's introduction upon the stage of the history, having been disposed of in the intermediate chapters. Shochoh which belongeth to Judah - See the marginal reference which places Shochoh and Azekah in the "Shephelah" or maritime plain, and 2 Chronicles 28:18 , "Shochoh" now "Shuweikeh," "nine miles from Eleutheropolis," Jerome. Ephes-dammim - Called "Happas-dammim" (Pas-dammim, 1 Chronicles 11:13 ), "the end of bloodshed," now "Damun," about 4 miles northeast of Shuweikeh.
Cross-References (TSK)
1Samuel 16:23; 1Samuel 17:2; 1Samuel 7:7; 1Samuel 13:5; 1Samuel 14:46; Judges 3:3; Joshua 15:35; 2Chronicles 11:7; 1Samuel 28:18; Joshua 10:10; Jeremiah 34:7; 1Chronicles 11:13; 1Samuel 17:1; 1Samuel 17:4; 1Samuel 17:12; 1Samuel 17:28; 1Samuel 17:30; 1Samuel 17:32; 1Samuel 17:38; 1Samuel 17:55; 1Samuel 15:2; 1Samuel 15:4; 1Samuel 14:23; Judges 20:4; 1Samuel 15:3; 1Samuel 14:21; 1Samuel 13:16; Judges 18:22; 1Samuel 4:1; 1Samuel 14:52; 1Samuel 15:5; Joshua 15:48; 1Samuel 16:18; 2Chronicles 11:9; 1Samuel 27:6; 1Samuel 25:22; 1Samuel 22:2; 2Samuel 23:9; 1Kings 4:10; 1Samuel 17:13