Ad Fontes ← Search Library Verse Index

Exodus 16:1–16:35

Manna in the WildernessTheme: Providence / Typology / Christ the BreadPericopeImportance: Significant
Sources
Reformed ConsensusReformation Study BibleCalvin (1560)Geneva Bible Notes (1599)John Trapp (1647)John Gill (1748)Matthew Henry (1714)Jamieson-Fausset-BrownBarnes (1832)Cross-References (TSK)
Reformed Consensus
The wilderness of Sin becomes the theater of both Israel's sinful ingratitude and God's sovereign provision, as the congregation's murmuring against Moses and Aaron is rightly identified by God as murmuring against Himself — exposing the deep corruption of a heart that had witnessed Egypt's plagues yet still doubted Yahweh's sufficiency (v. 8). In sovereign grace, God answers rebellion not with judgment but with bread from heaven, establishing a daily rhythm of dependence that Calvin rightly saw as a school of faith: each morning's manna taught Israel that man does not live by bread alone but by every word proceeding from God's mouth. The Sabbath institution embedded within the manna cycle (vv. 22–30) reveals that the fourth commandment was no Sinai innovation but a creational ordinance being renewed and reinforced, binding the conscience of the redeemed community to rest in God's provision rather than their own labor. The double portion on the sixth day and the miraculous preservation of the omer kept before the Testimony (v. 33) both underscore the confessional Reformed conviction that God's preserving providence is as sovereign as His initial act of creation. The entire episode finds its ultimate fulfillment in Christ, the true Bread of Heaven (John 6:32–35), of whom manna was a sacramental type, nourishing Israel outwardly in the desert as Christ nourishes His elect unto eternal life.
Reformation Study Bible
Israel arrives in time to observe the Sabbath and a theophany occurs in response to the people's complaints (16:9-13). The chapter draws to a close with a rest on the following Sabbath (16:27-30). Israel's keeping of the Sabbath prior to the revelation at Sinai is highlighted, as is God's continued testing of Israel (v. 4; cf. 15:25; 17:2). | wilderness of Sin. Situated in the southwest of Sinai, this is per- haps the modern region Debbet er-Ramleh. both (v. 8). Manna is called the “bread of the angels” (Ps. 78:25). In John 6:26-58, Jesus calls Himself the true manna (bread of life”) of which this provision in the wilderness was a symbol and type. | bread. The people cried for bread and meat (v, 3), and.God will give | am the Lorp, your healer. God has the power (Deut. 32:39) and the mercy to heal (Ps. 103:3). He alone can heal in the peace of His salvation (2 Chr. 16:12; Is. 38:17), To the prayer of anguish (Jer. 17:14), God responds (Jer. 30:17; 33:6). Healing from the damage inflicted by sin and death will come through the Lord’s Anointed, by whose wounds we are healed (Is. 53:5; 61:1,2; Matt. 8:17). | glory. The word normally refers to the manifested presence of God. Here, the Lord's gracious provision of the manna is in view, | quail, These small migratory game birds of the partridge family come from their winter habitat in Africa in the spring. They sometimes rest on the ground exhausted by flight. On a second wm they are brought by a strong east wind (Num. 11). | fine, flake-like thing. The manna seems to have been similar to a honey-like secretion of insects that infested the tamarisk plants of the area (called “manna” by the Arabs). It solidifies in the cold desert nights, but must be gathered early. If this is the manna, the miracle would be God's control of the amount. The amount gathered is an omer per man, about two quarts, though a related Arabic word means a cupful, and per- haps this is the meaning here. i | holy Sabbath. An elevated term normally reserved for holy festi- vals. The implication is that the weekly Sabbath was normally kept by Israel before Sinai, The Sabbath ordinance in the Ten Commandments was a codification of Sabbath observance, not its inauguration. | coriander. This seed is small, globular, grayish, and aromatic, tast- ing like honey cakes. | jar. The manna is set aside in what is called “the golden urn” in Heb. 9:4. | forty years. The manna continued until they came to Canaan (Josh. 5:10-12). When they reached the Transjordanian country they had fields, vineyards, and wells of water (Num. 21:22), but the manna seems to have continued.
Calvin (1560)
Exodus 16:1-8 1. And they took their journey from Elim; and all the congregation of the children of Israel came unto the wilderness of Sin, which is between Elim and Sinai, on the fifteenth day of the second month after their departing out of the land of Egypt. 1. Profectae autem ab Elim cunctae turmae filiorum Israel, venerunt in desertum Sin, quod est inter Elim et Sinai, quinto decimo die mensis secundi post eorum exitum e terra AEgypti. 2. And the whole congregation of the children of Israel murmured against Moses and Aaron in the wilderness. 2. Et murmuraverunt omnes turmae filiorum Israel contra Mosen et contra Aharon in deserto. 3. And the children of Israel said unto them, Would to God we had died by the hand of the Lord in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh-pots, and when we did eat bread to the full! for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger. 3. Et dixerunt ad eos filii Israel, Quis det ut mortui essemus per manum Jehovae in terra AEgypti, quando sedebamus juxta ollam carnis, et quando comedebamus panem in saturitate? Nam eduxistis nos in hoc desertum, ut interficeretis congregationem hanc fame. 4. Then said the Lord unto Moses, Behold, I will rain bread heaven for you; and the people shall go out and gather a certain rate everyday, that I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law, or no. 4. Tunc ait Jehova ad Mosen, Ecce, ego vobis pluam panem e coelo, et egredietur populus, et colligent summam diei die suo, ut probem eum, ambuletne in lege mea an non. 5. And it shall come to pass, that on the sixth day they shall prepare that which they bring in; and it shall be twice as much as they gather daily. 5. In die autem sexto parabunt quod inferant, et erit duplum prae eo quod colligent quotidie. 6. And Moses and Aaron said unto all the children of Israel, At even, then ye shall know that the Lord hath brought you out from the land of Egypt: 6. Et dixit Moses et Aharon ad universos filios Israel: Vespere scietis quod Jehova eduxerit vosa terra AEgypti. 7. And in the morning, then ye shall see the glory of the Lord; for that he heareth your murmurings against the Lord: and what are we, that ye murmur against us? 7. Mane autem videbitis gloriam Jehovae, quia audivit murmur vestrum contra Jehovam. Etenim nos quid sumus, ut murmuretis contra nos? 8. And Moses said, This shall be, when the Lord shall give you in the evening flesh to eat, and in the morning bread to the full; for that the Lord heareth your murmurings which ye murmur against him: and what are we? your murmurings are not against us, but against the Lord. 8. Et dixit Moses, Quum dederit vobis Jehova vespere carnem ad comedendum et panem mane ad saturitatem, ex quo audivit Jehova murmurationes vestras, quibus murmurastis contra eum. Quid enim? non contra nos murmurastis sed contra Jehovam. 1. And they took their journey. Moses relates, that, when after a month the people came to the wilderness of Sin near Mount Sinai, and when their provision failed, they rebelled against God and Moses, and manna, a new and unusual kind of food, was given them from heaven. It is uncertain with what foods they were sustained in the meantime. Some conjecture that they brought sufficient flour from Egypt for their supply; but to me it seems probable that other kinds of food were used in addition; for the barrenness of the country through which they passed was not so great but that it produced at least fruits and herbs. Besides, we may readily suppose, from the battle, in which it will soon be related that they conquered the Amalekites, that they were not far from an habitable territory. But, when they were carried away farther into the desert, all their provision began to fail, because they had no more commerce with the inhabitants. Hence their sedition was increased, because hunger pressed upon them more than usual. For, although we shall afterwards be able to gather from the context that there was some previous disturbance in the camp, still famine, which now began to affect them more, because in these uncultivated and miserable regions the barrenness on all sides alarmed them, gave strength to their murmurs and impatience. 2. And the whole congregation. Moses says not that some of the people only murmured, but that they were all gathered into mobs as in a conspiracy, or, at any rate, as they were arranged by hundreds and thousands, that they murmured with one consent. Yet the universal term admits of exception; nor need we suppose that all to a man were comprehended in this impious rebellion. The best remedy for their hunger would have been to pray to God, whom they had found to be in all respects a bountiful Father, and whom they had heard to have wonderfully provided for their parents, when the Egyptians and inhabitants of Canaan were wasting with hunger in such rich and fertile places. If they had only been persuaded that the earth is made fertile by God's blessing, it would at the same time have occurred to them, that it is His peculiar office to feed the hungry, and immediately they would have directed their prayers to Him; now, their unbelief betrays itself in their turbulent clamor. It is indeed astonishing that wretched men, whom their necessity should have humiliated, rose insolently against God, and that their hunger, so far from bending their hearts to gentleness, was the very incentive of their arrogance. But this is too common with the wicked, (because they do not trust that God is reconciled to them,) to neglect prayer, and to cry out in confusion, to utter their curses, and to rush, like mad dogs, furiously here and there. This was the case of the Israelites in the wilderness of Sin. The want of all things, which presents itself to them, is an invitation to them from God, that they may feel His power, by which He created the world out of nothing, to be independent of all foreign assistance for the maintenance of mankind. But despair seizes upon their faithless minds, so that they reject His aid and beneficence. And not only so, but their malignity and ingratitude instigates them to quarrel with Moses; and this is the sum of their complaint, that they were dragged away from abundance of bread and meat, that they might perish in the desert of hunger. Therefore they call Moses and Aaron, by whose hand and means they had been delivered, their murderers. 4. Then said the Lord unto Moses. It is probable that Moses passes over much in silence, because it is not consistent that the insolence of the people was left without even a single word of chastisement. For, although God in His extraordinary kindness gave food to these depraved and wicked men, who were unworthy of the sunlight and the common air, still He was without doubt unwilling to foster their sin by His silence, and, whilst He pardoned their ingratitude, sharply reproved their forwardness. But Moses, passing over this, proceeds to a history especially worthy of narration, how God fed this wretched people with bread from heaven, when He made the manna to fall from the clouds like dew. I call it "the bread of heaven," with the Prophet, ( Psalm 78:24 ,) who honors it with this magnificent title, and extols God's bounty towards His people, as if they had been admitted to the tables of angels. For St. Paul calls the manna "spiritual meat," ( 1 Corinthians 10:3 ,) in another sense, viz., because it was a type of the flesh of Christ, which feeds our minds unto the hope of eternal life. The Prophet, however, makes no allusion to that mystery, but alleges in this circumstance an accusation against the people, because they not only despised the food which springs from the earth, but also were disgusted with that bread, for which they saw the heavens in a manner opened. But on this point somewhat must be hereafter repeated. God now declares that He will give them daily their allowance, as it were, that in this way He may prove the obedience of His people. Though on this latter head interpreters are not agreed; for some understand it as if God, by kindly providing food for the Israelites, would bind them to obedience by His bounty; as though He should say, "I will try whether they are altogether intractable or submissive; for nothing shall be wanting to retain them in the way of duty." But others confine the meaning of the word to "their daily food;" for that this was the proof of their fear and reverence, that they should not desire more than was given them, but that they should he contented with their daily provision, and thus depend on the providence of God. The former sense pleases me best, and I have endeavored to explain it more clearly than it can be understood from others. There is no occasion to enter into controversy about the word "Law," [171] for (as we shall soon see) it is used to express the measure or rule of a pious and just life. Therefore, He says, that He will know whether they are disposed to honor Him, and to submit themselves to His command. But if any one prefer to embrace the other sense, I leave him to enjoy his own opinion. 5. And it shall come to pass. Because mention is immediately made of the Sabbath, some would confine to its observance what is said respecting the law, and extract this sense from it, that God made the experiment whether the people would faithfully observe the rest enjoined to them on each seventh day. But there is a poorness in this explanation. The fact is, that after God had promised daily supplies to His people, He now adds the exception, viz., that on the sixth day they should collect a double quantity, and lay aside half of it for the use of the Sabbath. Thus the seventh day was really hallowed before the promulgation of the Law, although it is questionable whether it had already been observed by the patriarchs. It appears probable that it was; but I am unwilling to make it a matter of contention. 6. And Moses and Aaron said. The statement that the people should know that their coming out of the land of Egypt was the Lord's work, is opposed to their wicked taunt, in which they had complained of being betrayed by Moses and Aaron, when they had been brought into the wilderness. They therefore answer, that God would openly show that He was the author of their deliverance, that they should make no more complaints against His ministers. But although a sharp reproof is implied, still it is joined with a promise of God's continued favor. They therefore admonish them, that by this event it would be proved that God was the Leader and Deliverer of the Israelites, because he does not leave the work of His hands unfinished. ( Psalm 138:8 .) The continuance, then, of His favor, shows that the same God, who proceeds in the prosecution of His powerful work, had from the first begun what He carries on even to the end. The knowledge, which they were to receive in the evening, refers to the quails, in which God gave an instance of His power; but, because it shone forth more brightly next day in the manna, Moses says, that in the morning they should see the glory of the Lord. But, lest they should be induced by this favor to think highly of themselves, and should flatter themselves in their iniquity, he reminds them that this was not given them in return for their sins, but that God contended after this manner with their obstinate perversity; as much as to say that God would appear to them, so that, beholding by the brightness of His countenance their own impiety, they might altogether be filled with shame, and feel the profaneness of the rebellion with which they had dared to insult Him. And, lest they should prevaricate, and say that they had only made an attack upon Moses and Aaron, he gives the reason why he declares them to have waged war against God Himself, viz., because neither he nor his brother had acted of themselves, nor had personally assumed anything in the matter; for this is the meaning of the words, "what are we, that ye murmur against us?" as if he disclaimed any separation from God. Now, since by this testimony he proves himself to have been a faithful servant; of God, we gather that none may rightly claim honor for themselves in the Church, so as to be accounted lawful pastors, but those who are divinely called, and thus have God. as the authorizer of their office, and who advance nothing of themselves, but only execute what is commanded them. Whilst such as these [172] may not be despised without dishonoring God, whose person they represent, so do they, who exercise dominion with no authority but their own, vainly alarm the simple in God's name, and [173] instead of the truth, are only wearing' an empty mask. The eighth verso merely contains an exposition of the same sentiment, except that he goes on to say in connection, that the Israelites, when in the evening they shall have been filled with flesh, and when bread shall have been given them in the morning, would perceive that God is their Deliverer. Then comes the antithesis, "Your murmurings are not against us, but against the Lord." Footnotes: [171] "Some refer this probation or trial to that particular law and precept of gathering but a certain portion of manna every day. So Vatablus, Borrha, Galas., Tostat., Rupert. Some understand it as well of that precept, as of the other, not to gather any upon the Sabbath. -- Simler. Some will have it taken more largely of all the precepts, and commandments touching manna, which were eight in all. -- Lyranus. But it is better to take it in a more general sense. The Lord, as he had tried them before with crosses and adversities, so now he would prove them by His benefits, to see whether they will afterward walk in His fear, and in obedience before Him. So Ferus, Calvin, Osiand., Pelarg. And thus by this particular benefit God would prepare them to the obedience of His law, which should be given afterwards. -- Oleaster." -- Willet's Hexapla in loco. [172] "Qui resemblent a Moyse." -- Fr. [173] "Et sont a rejetter comme pipeurs, veu qu'ils n'ont qu'une fausse masque pour la verite;" and must be rejected as deceivers, since they have only a false masque instead of the truth. -- Fr.
Geneva Bible Notes (1599)
And they took their journey from Elim, and all the congregation of the children of Israel came unto the wilderness of {a} Sin, which is between Elim and Sinai, on the fifteenth day of the second month after their departing out of the land of Egypt. (a) This is the eighth place in which they had camped, there is another place called Zin, which was the 33rd place in which they camped, and is also called Kadesh, Nu 33:36.
John Trapp (1647)
And they took their journey from Elim, and all the congregation of the children of Israel came unto the wilderness of Sin, which [is] between Elim and Sinai, on the fifteenth day of the second month after their departing out of the land of Egypt. Unto the wilderness of Sin. — So called because it bordered upon the city of Sin, whereof see Ezekiel 30:15-16 ; Ezekiel 20:35-36 . Or, of the many brambles that grew therein.
John Gill (1748)
And they took their journey from Elim,.... And came again to the Red sea, as appears from Numbers 33:10 perhaps to some bay or creek of it, which ran up from it, and lay in their way, and where for a short time they encamped to look at it, and recollect what had been done for them in bringing them through it; but as their stay here was short, and nothing of any importance or consequence happened, it is here omitted, and their next station is only observed: and all the congregation of the children of Israel came unto the wilderness of Sin, which still bears the same name, as a late traveller (a) informs us, who passed through it, and says, we traversed these plains in nine hours, being all the way diverted with the sight of a variety of lizards and vipers, that are here in great numbers; and elsewhere (b) he says, that vipers, especially in the wilderness of Sin which might very properly be called "the inheritance of dragons", were very dangerous and troublesome, not only our camels, but the Arabs who attended them, running every moment the risk of being bitten. The Red sea, or the bay of it, they came to from Elim, according to Bunting (c) was six miles, and from thence to the wilderness of Sin, sixteen more. This is a different wilderness from that of Zin, which is written with a different letter, Numbers 20:1 and was on the other side of Mount Sinai, as this was the way to it, as follows: which is between Elim and Sinai according to the above writer (d), it was twenty miles from Elim the Israelites travelled, and forty more ere they came to Sinai. Dr. Shaw (e) says, after traversing the plains in nine hours, we were near twelve hours in passing the many windings and difficult ways which lie beteen those deserts and these of Sinai; the latter consists of a beautiful plain more than a league in breadth, and nearly three in length: on the fifteenth day of the second month, after their departing out of the land of Egypt; the month Ijar, as the Targum of Jonathan, which answers to part of April and part of May, and has its name from the beauty of the flowers, which appear at this time of the year: the Israelites were now come from thence a month or thirty days; for they came out the fifteenth of Abib or Nisan, and now it was the fifteenth of Ijar; and as the first day of this month, as Jarchi says, was on the first day of the week, this day must be so likewise; and yet sometimes the Jews say (f) this was a sabbath day. (a) Shaw, p. 314. (b) lb p. 444. (c) Travels, p. 82. (d) Ib. (e) Travels, p. 314. (f) T. Bab. Sabbat, fol. 87. 2.
Matthew Henry (1714)
The provisions of Israel, brought from Egypt, were spent by the middle of the second month, and they murmured. It is no new thing for the greatest kindness to be basely represented as the greatest injuries. They so far undervalue their deliverance, that they wished they had died in Egypt; and by the hand of the Lord, that is, by the plagues which cut off the Egyptians. We cannot suppose they had plenty in Egypt, nor could they fear dying for want in the wilderness, while they had flocks and herds: none talk more absurdly than murmurers. When we begin to fret, we ought to consider, that God hears all our murmurings. God promises a speedy and constant supply. He tried whether they would trust him, and rest satisfied with the bread of the day in its day. Thus he tried if they would serve him, and it appeared how ungrateful they were. When God plagued the Egyptians, it was to make them know he was their Lord; when he provided for the Israelites, it was to make them know he was their God.
Jamieson-Fausset-Brown
CHAPTER 16 Ex 16:1-36. Murmurs for Want of Bread. 1. they took their journey from Elim—where they had remained several days. came unto the wilderness of Sin—It appears from Nu 32:1-42, that several stations are omitted in this historical notice of the journey. This passage represents the Israelites as advanced into the great plain, which, beginning near El-Murkah, extends with a greater or less breadth to almost the extremity of the peninsula. In its broadest part northward of Tur it is called El-Kaa, which is probably the desert of Sin [Robinson].The children of Israel sojourn in the wilderness of Sin, Exodus 16:1 ; murmur against Moses, Exodus 16:2 ,3 . God promises to supply their wants with bread from heaven, Exodus 16:4 ; and directs about preparing this bread, Exodus 16:5 . Moses reproves the people for murmuring, Exodus 16:7 ,8 ; appoints them to come before the Lord, Exodus 16:9 . God’s glory appeareth in the cloud, Exodus 16:10 . He sendeth quails, Exodus 16:13 , and manna, Exodus 16:14 ,15 . Every one gather a quantity, Exodus 16:16-18 . The command about keeping it, Exodus 16:19 , is disobeyed, Exodus 16:20 . The time of gathering, Exodus 16:21 . Their increasing the quantity on the sixth day, Exodus 16:22-24 . The command concerning the sabbath, Exodus 16:25 ,26 , disobeyed, Exodus 16:27 ; for which God is angry, Exodus 16:28 . Moses’ s counsel, Exodus 16:29 . They rest, Exodus 16:30 . The name of the bread, Exodus 16:31 . The command concerning the preservation of the manna, Exodus 16:32 ,33 . The time of the manna’s continuance, Exodus 16:35 . BC 1491 They came not immediately to the wilderness of Sin ; for there is another stage of theirs by the Red Sea, mentioned Numbers 33:10 , (in which chapter Moses designed exactly to set down all their stations,) but omitted here, because nothing remarkable happened in it; and Moses in this place designed to record only the memorable passages. The wilderness of Sin was a great wilderness between the Red Sea and Mount Sinai, but differing from that Zin mentioned Numbers 20:1 .
Barnes (1832)
The the wilderness of Sin - The desert tract, called Debbet er Ramleh, extend nearly across the peninsula from the Wady Nasb in a south-easterly direction, between the limestone district of Et Tih and the granite of Sinai. The journey from the station at Elim, or even from that on the Red Sea, could be performed in a day: at that time the route was kept in good condition by the Egyptians.
Cross-References (TSK)
Exodus 15:27; Exodus 16:2; Numbers 33:10; Exodus 17:1; Numbers 33:12; Ezekiel 30:15; Exodus 16:1; Exodus 16:4; Exodus 16:13; Exodus 16:16; Exodus 16:25; Exodus 16:32; Exodus 15:19; Exodus 12:47; Genesis 35:18; 2Peter 1:15; Exodus 15:9; Luke 3:2; Exodus 15:22; Exodus 13:5; Exodus 4:8; Exodus 10:17; Galatians 4:25; Psalms 73:27; Exodus 19:1; Exodus 16:3; Numbers 33:9; Leviticus 23:34; Exodus 16:22